Bellarmine · De Scriptoribus Ecclesiasticis · On the Ecclesiastical Writers
Chapter 37: Tostado, Panormitanus, Antoninus, Aeneas Sylvius, Laurence Justinian, Torquemada, Bessarion
Our translation, from the Latin of the Opera Omnia (Paris: Vivès, 1870–74), vol. XII, De Scriptoribus Ecclesiasticis, of the New Testament, fifteenth century. The Latin source text is public domain; this English rendering is released with the site. Scripture quotations follow Bellarmine's Vulgate citations, rendered in Douay-Rheims wording where he quotes exactly. Click “Show the Latin” for the original (raw OCR of the scan; scanning errors remain — the scan itself is the authority).
Alphonsus Tostado. 1440
Alphonsus Tostado, a Spaniard by nation, Bishop of Avila, a man most celebrated for holiness and learning, lived in the time of the Pontiff Eugene the fourth, about the year of the Lord 1440. He wrote most copious commentaries on the Pentateuch, on Joshua, Judges and Ruth, and also on the books of Kings and of Chronicles, and on the Gospel of St. Matthew; in which commentaries he resolved innumerable questions, so that it was rightly written of him: “Here is the wonder of the world, who discusses everything that can be known.” And what is more to be wondered at, he wrote so much in a very short time, since he lived only forty years. Nor did he write only those commentaries, but also very many little works, of which these are extant:
A Defence of three conclusions.
A book On the holy Trinity.
A book against concubinary Priests.
Paradoxes.
An Explanation of the words of Isaiah, Behold a Virgin shall conceive.
A book On the state of souls after death.
A book On the best polity.
Biondo the Historian. 1440
Flavio Biondo, of Forlì by birth, was secretary to Eugene the fourth, supreme Pontiff; and he wrote a Roman history, in which many Church matters are contained, from the decline of the empire down to his own times, that is, from the year of the Lord 407 to the year 1440.
Nicholas of Palermo. 1440
Nicholas Tudeschis, a Sicilian by nation, of Catania by birth, of the order of St. Benedict, an Abbot, and afterwards Archbishop of Palermo, and at last created Cardinal of the Holy Roman Church, but in the schism, by Felix the fifth, the Antipope. He was a man most skilled in canon law, and wrote very many things, which are contained in eight volumes in the Venice edition of the year 1592.
In the first and second volumes are commentaries on the first book of the decretals.
In the third, fourth and fifth volumes are commentaries on the second book of the decretals.
In the sixth volume are commentaries on the third of the decretals.
In the seventh volume are commentaries on the fourth and fifth of the decretals, and on the Clementines.
In the eighth volume are 226 counsels, and seven questions.
Also a re-reading on the chapter Per tuas, on Arbiters.
Also his practice.
He is said also to have written a commentary, begun, on the decree; but I do not know whether it is extant. He is said also to have written a book for the council of Basel; but it is credible that this book, as written in a bad cause, and so erroneous, was struck out from his works. I certainly have found it nowhere among his works in their various editions. And although this author sat in the Council of Basel, even at the time when the Council was headless and schismatic, yet in this he behaved well: that when they were bringing a multitude of Priests into the Council, for want of Bishops, he contradicted them most freely, as Aeneas Sylvius, who was present, testifies in his history of the Council of Basel. For he knew, and taught, that in Councils, especially general ones, there is no place for simple Priests as to the deciding vote, unless they held the place of absent Bishops. Nicholas, the Abbot of Palermo, died in the year 1445.
St. Antoninus of Florence. 1445
St. Antoninus, a Florentine by birth, of the Order of Preachers, and afterwards Archbishop of Florence, a most learned and most holy man, died in the year of the Lord 1459, in the seventieth year of his age; the Pontiff Adrian VI enrolled him in the catalogue of saints.
He wrote a historical summa divided into three parts.
A theological summa, divided into four parts.
A book On the instruction of Confessors, which is called Defecerunt, because it begins, Defecerunt scrutinio.
He is said also to have written a dialogue of three on Christ and the two disciples going to Emmaus, in which are explained all the things that were foretold of the life, death and Resurrection of the Lord.
Aeneas Sylvius. 1450
Aeneas Sylvius, of Siena by birth, a learned man, prudent and of great spirit, first secretary to the emperor, then Bishop of Siena, then Cardinal, at last supreme Pontiff as Pius the second, died in the year of the Lord 1464, while he was preparing a great expedition against the Turks, the enemies of the name of Christ.
He wrote one book on Church matters against the Taborites.
To Nicholas of Cusa, one book.
On the Faith, to the emperor of the Turks.
On the history of the Bohemians.
On the disaster of Constantinople.
On the disaster of the universal Church.
On the assembly of Mantua, an Oration.
To Pope Callixtus, an Oration.
To the Cardinals, an Oration.
An Epitome of the Decades of Biondo.
Many letters.
On the Council of Basel, two books.
A Retractation.
Commentaries on the things done by himself.
A Reply to Martin Mair on behalf of the Roman Church.
He wrote besides many things belonging to humane letters, to poetry, and to the description of countries.
First observation. What Aeneas wrote for the Council of Basel when he was young, he retracted when old and supreme Pontiff. And although those books on the Council of Basel were rightly forbidden by the Catholic Church, yet the heretics of Basel, who lately reprinted the same books, brought harm not so much to the Catholic Church as to their own cause. For from that history of Aeneas Sylvius on the Council of Basel it appears that the Council was lawful at the beginning; but that when those Fathers set about deposing the true Pontiff Eugene the fourth, they no longer had the form of a true Council, not only because it was headless, but also because, against the form of all the ancient Councils, there were more Priests in that assembly with a deciding vote than Bishops. For it is very well known that general councils, as also provincial ones, belong to Bishops, not to lesser Priests; for so we read in the Council of Chalcedon, in the first session: “Send out those who have no business here; the Council is of Bishops.” See, if you please, what we have written in book 3 On the Church, chapter 16.
Second observation. There are extant commentaries on the deeds of Pius the second under the name of John Gobellinus; but it is doubtful whether that work is by the Pontiff Pius himself, or truly by him under whose name it came out. For the same commentaries are extant in manuscript under the name of Pius the second, and the style seems to be the same in this work and in the others of the same author; but the matter is not of great moment.
Andrea Barbazza. 1460
Andrea Barbazza, a Sicilian, flourished in the year 1460. He wrote on the Decretals. He wrote also On the excellence of the Cardinals. He wrote also various counsels.
Laonicus Chalcondyles. 1460
Laonicus Chalcondyles of Athens wrote a history in ten books on the origin and deeds of the Turks down to his own times, that is, to the year of the Lord 1462; to which history an appendix is added, by which the history is continued to the year of the Lord 1565. We place this author among the Church writers because his history contains very many things belonging to Christian affairs.
Yet because this author was put into Latin by a heretical man, and enlarged with notes set in the margin, his reading is found forbidden in the index of prohibited books. Laonicus himself also is not free of false stories, which he rashly believed, being ignorant of our affairs.
John of Bassoles. 1460
John of Bassoles, of the order of Minors, wrote commentaries not to be despised on the four books of the sentences. He was living in the year of the Lord 1466 [as printed; he was a hearer of Scotus, of the fourteenth century].
Blessed Laurence Justinian. 1440
Blessed Laurence Justinian, a Venetian by birth, first a Canon Regular, then Bishop of Venice, lastly the first Patriarch of the same City, flourished in learning, holiness and miracles in the times of Eugene the fourth and Nicholas the fifth, Roman Pontiffs, about the year of the Lord 1440. He died in the year 1456. He wrote fifteen volumes, of which these are the titles:
The Tree of life.
On monastic discipline.
On the marriage of the Word and the soul.
On humility.
On the spiritual death of the soul.
On the triumphal contest of Christ.
On the inner conflict.
On the lament of the Church.
On the body and blood of Christ.
On the solitary life.
On contempt of the world.
On the Lord's discourse at the supper.
On the Pastoral office.
On obedience.
On the degrees of perfection.
He wrote besides forty sermons. He died in the seventy-fourth [the second figure is damaged in the scan] year of his age, the twenty-fourth of his Episcopate; but in the last five years he was also Patriarch.
John of Torquemada. 1440
John of Torquemada, a Spaniard by nation, of the Order of Preachers, Cardinal Priest of St. Sixtus, created by Eugene the fourth, afterwards Cardinal Bishop of Sabina, an eminent Theologian and jurist, died in the year of the Lord 1468, older than 80.
He wrote a summa On the Church, four books.
An Apparatus on the decree of Eugene the fourth on the union of the Greeks with the Latins.
Commentaries on the decree of Gratian.
On the Psalter.
On the Sunday Gospels.
On the Gospels of the saints.
On the body of Christ, against the Bohemians.
On the salvation of the soul.
On holy water.
On the Conception of the Blessed Virgin.
On the rule of St. Benedict.
Meditations on the life of Christ.
Matteo Palmieri. 1440
Matteo Palmieri of Florence lived at the time of the Council of Florence, as he himself testifies in the chronicle. He wrote, or continued, the Chronicle from the year 449, where St. Prosper left off, to the year 1449. John Trithemius indeed writes that this Matteo was afterwards convicted of heresy and condemned; but in his chronicle I have found no trace of error.
Mattia Palmieri. 1440
Mattia Palmieri of Pisa lived in the same century, and continued the chronicle of Matteo from the year 1450 to 1481.
Cardinal Bessarion. 1440
Bessarion, a Greek by nation, of Trebizond by birth, by rank Bishop of Nicaea, afterwards Cardinal of the Holy Roman Church, created by the Pontiff Eugene the fourth, having carried out many legations and been worn by many other pious labours, died in the year of the Lord 1472, while Sixtus the fourth sat.
He wrote an oration for the union, long and most learned, which is extant in Greek and Latin in session 25 of the Council of Florence.
He wrote also another shorter one, which likewise is extant in Greek and Latin, in session 1 of the same Council.
He wrote also a book against Mark Epherius [as printed; Mark of Ephesus] in defence of the Roman Church.
He wrote also on the words of consecration against the same Mark.
He wrote on that saying of John 21, So I will have him remain till I come.
He wrote lastly many philosophical things in defence of Plato; and he put the metaphysics of Aristotle into Latin; and he is said to have sent three books of consolation to the emperor of the Greeks.
Show the Latin (Vives edition, OCR)
De A Iphonso Tonstato. 1440. Alphonsus Tonstatus natione Hispanus Episcopus Abulensis, vir sanctitate et do¬ ctrina celeberrimus, vixit tempore Eugenii quarti Pontificis, circa annum Dom. 1440. Scripsit commentaria copiosissimam Pen¬ tateuchum, in Josue, Judices et Ruth : nec non in libros Regum, et Paralipomenon, 'et in Evangelium Sancti Matthaei : in quibus commentariis dissoluit quaestiones innume¬ rabiles, ut merito de eo scriptum sit : « Hic stupor est mundi, qui scibile discutit omne, » et quod magis est admirandum, tanta scri¬ psit brevissimo tempore, cum non vixerit nisi annos quadraginta. Neque solum com¬ mentaria illa scripsit, sed etiam opuscula plurima, e quibus exstant : Defensorium trium conclusionum. Liber de sancta Trinitate. Liber contra Sacerdotes concubinarios. Paradoxa. Explicatio verborum Isaiae, Ecce Virgo concipiet. Liber de statu animarum post mortem. Liber de optima politica. De Blondo Historico. 1440. V • Flavius Blondus patriaForoliviensis, a se¬ cretis fuit Eugenio quarto summo Pontifici; et scripsit historiam Romanam, in qua mul¬ ta Ecclesiastica continentur, ab inclinatione imperii usque ad sua tempora, id est, ab anno Domini 407. usque ad an. 1440. De Nicolao Panormitano. 1440. Nicolaus Tudescus, natione Siculus, patria Catanensis, ord. S. Benedicti, Abbas, et po¬ stea ArchiepiscopusPanormitanus, ac demum S. R. E. Cardinalis creatus, sed in schismate, a Felice quinto Antipapa. Vir fuit juris ca¬ nonici peritissimus, et plurima scripsit, quae tomis octo comprehenduntur in editione Veneta anni 1592. In primo et secundo tomo habentur com¬ mentaria in primum librum decretalium. In tertio, quarto, et quinto tomo habentur commentaria in secundum librum decreta¬ lium. In sexto tomo habentur commentaria in tertium decretalium. In septimo tomo habentur commentaria in quartum et quintum decretalium : et in epistolas Clementinas. In octavo tomo habentur Concilia 226. quaestiones septem. Item relectio in cap. Per tuas, de Arbi¬ tris. Item practica ejusdem. Dicitur etiam scripsisse commentarium inchoatum in decretum : sed nescio, an exstet. Dicitur etiam scripsisse librum pro conc. Basileensi, sed hunc librum, ut in mala causa scriptum, et proinde erroneum, cre¬ dibile est ex ejus operibus abrasum fuisse. Ego certe inter ejus opera variarum editio¬ num eum nusquam reperi. Quamvis autem hic auctor sederit in Concilio Basileensi, etiam quo tempore Concilium acephalum et schismaticum erat : tamen iu eo bene se gessit, quod introducentibus in Concilium multitudinem Presbyterorum, ob defectum Episcoporum, liberrime contradixit : ut te¬ statur iEneas Sylvius, qui praesens aderat, in historia Concilii Basileensis. Sciebat enim, et docebat, in Conciliis, praesertim ge¬ neralibus, locum non esse simplicibus Pre¬ sbyteris, quoad votum decisivum, nisi locum tenerent absentium Episcoporum. Obiit Ni¬ colaus, Abbas Panormitanus, anno 1445. De S. Antonino Florentino. 1445. Sanctus Antoninus, patria Florentinus, Ordinis Praedicatorum, ac postea Florentiae Archiepiscopus, vir doctissimus, et sanctissi¬ mus, obiit anno Dom. 1459, aetatis septua- gessimo, quem in sanctorum catalogum re¬ tulit Adrianus VI. Pontifex. 465 AB ANNO DOM. 1400. AU 1500. Scripsit summam historialem in tres par¬ tes divisam. Summam theologicam, in quatuor partes divisam. Librum de eruditione Confessorum, qui dicitur Defecerunt, quia incipit, Defecerunt scrutinio. Dicitur etiam scripsisse trialogum de Chri¬ sto, et duobus discipulis euntibus in Emmaiis, in quo explicantur omnia quae de vita, morte, et Resurrectione Domini praedicta sunt. De sEnea Sylvio. 1450. . m Hrr iit iri xEneas Sylvius, patria Senensis, vir do¬ ctus, prudens, et magni animi, ac primum a secretis imperatoris, deinde Episcopus Se¬ nensis, tum Cardinalis, denique summus Pontifex Pius secundus, dum expeditionem magnam adversus Tureas Christi mi nomi¬ nis hostes moliretur, obiit anno Dom. 1464. Scripsit de rebus Ecclesiasticis contra Thaboritas librum unum. Ad Nicolaum de Cusa lib. 1. De Fide ad imperatorem Turearum. De historia Bohemorum. De clade Constantinopolitana. De clade universalis Ecclesiae. De conventu Mantuano, Oratio. Ad Calixtum Papam, Oratio. Ad Cardinales Oratio. Decadum Blondi, Epitomem. Epistolas multas. De Concilio Basileensi, libros duos. Retractationem. Commentaria de rebus a se gestis. Responsionem ad Martinum Mejer pro Ecclesia Romana. Scripsit praeterea multa ad humanita¬ tem, ad poesim, ad chorographiam pertinentia. i ■ '!«•./*. v« >ei"sv «ib ft-roo M Observatio prima. Si ^ ;yV. * K 1 • \ . x - > Quse scripsit iEneas pro Concilio Basileen¬ si, cum juvenis esset, retractavit senex, et Pontifex Maximus : et quamvis libri illi de Concilio Basileensi merito prohibiti ab Ecclesia Catholica ; tamen haeretici Ba- sileenses, qui nuper eosdem libros recude- runt, non tam Ecclesiae Catholicae, quam causas suae detrimentum attulerunt. Siqui¬ dem ex historia illa dSneaeSylvii de Concilio Basileensi, apparet illud Concilium initio fuisse legitimum : sed ubi verum Pontificem Tom. XII. Eugenium quartum deponere aggressi sunt Patres illi jam non habuisse formam veri Concilii, non solum, quod acephalum esset, sed etiam quod contra formam omnium ve¬ terum Conciliorum plures essent in eo con¬ ventu Presbyteri cum voce decisiva, quam Episcopi : notissimum enim est, concilia generalia, ut etiam provincialia, Episcopo¬ rum esse, non minorum Sacerdotum : sic enim legimus in Concilio Chalcedonensi actione prima, « Mitte foras superfluos ; Concilium Episcoporum est. » Vide, si pla¬ cet, quse scripsimus lib. m. de Ecclesia cap. 16. Observatio secunda. ♦ Exstant commentaria de rebus gestis Pii secundi sub nomine Joannis Gobellini, sed dubium est, an illud opus sit ipsius Pii Pon¬ tificis, an vero ejus, sub cujus nomine pro¬ diit : exstant enim manuscripsa commenta¬ ria eadem sub nomine Pii secundi et stylus videtur esse idem in hoc opere, et in aliis ejusdem auctoris, sed res non est magni momenti. De Andrea Barbatio. 1460. >1 Wl* . Andreas Barbatius Siculus, floruit anno 1460. . . Scripsit in Decretales. Scripsit etiam de Cardinalium praestan¬ tia. Scripsit quoque varia concilia. ilo-ij' c-iij. . j j De Laonico Chalcondyla. 1460. Laonicus Chalcondyla Atheniensis, scri¬ psit historiam libris decem, de origine et rebus gestis Turearum usque ad sua tem¬ pora, id est, ad annum Dom. 1462., cui historia? adjecta est appendix, qua continua¬ tur historia usque ad annum Dom. 1565. Hunc auctorem ponimus inter Ecclesiasticos, quoniam ejus historia plui ima continet ad res Christianas pertinentia. Quia tamen hic auctor ab Haeretico homine latinitate donatus est, et annotationibus in margine positis auctus in indice librorum prohibitorum, ejus lectio interdicta inveni¬ tur. Ipse etiam Laonicus non caret narratio¬ nibus falsis, quas temere credidit rerum no¬ strarum ignarus. f n 30 I I / DE SCRIPTORIBUS ECCLESIASTICIS De Joanne Bassoho. 1460. Joannes Bassolius ordinis Minorum, scri¬ psit in quatuor libros sententiarum non con¬ temnenda commentaria. Vivebat anno Dom. 1466. De Beato Laurentio Justiniano. 1440. B. Laurentius Justinianus, patria Venetus, ac primum Canonicus Regularis , deinde Episcopus Venetiarum , postremo primus ejusdem Urbis Patriarcha, floruit doctrina, sanctitate, et miraculis, temporibus Eugenii quarti, et Nicolai quinti Pontificum Roma¬ norum, circa annum Dom. 1440. Obiit anno 1456. Scripsit volumina quindecim, quarum hi sunt tituli : Lignum vitae. De disciplina monastica. De connubio Verbi, et animse. De humilitate. De spirituali interitu animse. . De triumphali agone Christi. De interiori conflictu. De complanctu Ecclesias. De corpore, et sanguine Christi. De vita solitaria. De contemptu mundi. De sermone Domini in coena. De officio Pastorali. De obedientia. De gradibus perfectionis. Scripsit praeterea sermones quadraginta. Obiit anno aetatis 7 i., Episcopatus vicesimo quarto, sed quinque annis ultimis fuit etiam Patriarcha. De Joanne de Turrecremata. 1440. Joannes de Turrecremata, natione Hispa¬ nus, Ordinis Praedicatorum Cardinalis Pre¬ sbyter S. Sixli ab Eugenio quarto creatus? postea Episcopus Cardinalis Sabinus, Theo¬ logus, et jureconsultus eximius obiit anno Dom. 1468. aetatis 80. major. Scripsit summam de Ecclesia, quatuor libros. Apparatum super decretum Eugenii quarti de unione Graecorum cum Lati¬ nis. , Commentaria in decretum Gratiani, n Psalterium. In Evangelia dominicalia. In Evangelia de sanctis. De corpore Christi contra Bohemos. De salute animae. De aqua benedicta. De Conceptione B. Virginis. In regulam Sancti Benedicti. Meditationes de vita Christi. De Matthaeo Palmerio. 1440. Matthaeus Palmerius Florentinus, vixit tempore Concilii Flor entini, ut ipse testatur in chronico. Scripsit, sive continuavit Chro¬ nicam ab anno 449., ubi desiit S. Prosper, usque ad annum 1449. Scribit quidem Jo. Trithemius, hunc Matthaeum postea de hae- resi convictum, et damnatum fuisse, sed in chronico ipsius nullum ego erroris inveni ve¬ stigium. De Matthia Palmerio. 1440. Matthias Palmerius Pisanus, vixit eodem saeculo, et continuavit chronicum Matthaei ab anno 1450, usque ad 1481. De Bessarione Cardinali. 1440. Bessarion natione Graecus, patria Trape- zuntius, dignitate Episcopus Nicaenus, pos¬ tea Cardinalis S. II. E. ab Eugenio quarto Pontifice creatus, multis legationibus per¬ functus, multisque aliis piis laboribus fati¬ gatus, obiit anno Dom. 1472., Sixto quarto sedente. Scripsit orationem pro unione, prolixam, et doctissimam, quae exstat Graece et Latine sess. 25. Concilii Florentini. Scripsit quoque aliam breviorem, quae pariter exstat Graece et Latine, sessione 1. ejusdem Concilii. Scripsit etiam librum adversus Marcum Epherium pro defensione Ecclesiae Romanae. Scripsit quoque de verbis consecrationis adversus eumdern Marcum. Scripsit de illo Joannis XXI. Sic eum volo munere donec veniam. Scripsit denique multa philosophica in defensionem Platonis : et metaphysicam Aristotelis latinitate donavit : et libros tres consolatorios ad imperatorem Graecorum mi¬ sisse dicitur.