Faith & the Word

Bellarmine · De Scriptoribus Ecclesiasticis · On the Ecclesiastical Writers

Chapter 15: The End of the Fourth Century: Theophilus, Rufinus, Palladius, Gaudentius, Prudentius, Chromatius, Chrysostom, Severian

Our translation, from the Latin of the Opera Omnia (Paris: Vivès, 1870–74), vol. XII, De Scriptoribus Ecclesiasticis, of the New Testament, fourth century. The Latin source text is public domain; this English rendering is released with the site. Scripture quotations follow Bellarmine's Vulgate citations, rendered in Douay-Rheims wording where he quotes exactly. Click “Show the Latin” for the original (raw OCR of the scan; scanning errors remain — the scan itself is the authority).

Theophilus of Alexandria. 390

Theophilus, Bishop of the Church of Alexandria, a contemporary of St. Jerome, as the letters each wrote to the other testify, wrote three Easter letters, which St. Jerome put into Latin. And these fairly useful and learned letters are extant in the Library of the Holy Fathers, volume 3. He wrote besides against Origen, and other things which Gennadius mentions in the book On Illustrious Men; but these are not extant.

John, Bishop of Jerusalem. 390

John, Bishop of Jerusalem, lived in the time of St. Jerome, as is known from the quarrels more than once stirred up between them. He wrote, on the witness of Gennadius, a book against the detractors of his pursuit, showing that he was not an Origenist. There is attributed to the same John a book to Caprasius on the instruction of a Monk, which is found in the Library of the Holy Fathers, volume 9, second edition. But this book seems written by someone much later; since in that book the author says he is of the order of Carmelites, and describes the habit of the Carmelites; but in those times the name of Carmelite religious was plainly unheard of, as Cardinal Baronius too affirms, Annals volume 6, at the year 444. Add that the style is of a Latin man, and of later times.

Diadochus. 390

Diadochus, Bishop of Photice, wrote a notable book on perfection, containing a hundred chapters. This book is extant in the Library of the Holy Fathers, volume 5, second edition.

Dorotheus the Archimandrite

Dorotheus the Archimandrite wrote twenty-four sermons, which are extant in the Library of the Holy Fathers, volume 2, second edition. When these two lived I have not found out, though it is clear enough that they were ancient.

Rufinus the Presbyter. 390

Rufinus, Presbyter of Aquileia, once a very close friend of St. Jerome, then become his rival, wrote two books of Church history, which he added to the history of Eusebius of Caesarea that he had turned from the Greek. He wrote also an explanation of the Apostles' creed; likewise commentaries on some Psalms; two invectives against St. Jerome; and an apology for Origen, in which he tells many lies, on the witness of Jerome himself in the second apology. He wrote also many letters. All these are extant, partly among the works of St. Jerome, partly in the history of Eusebius, partly also separately. He turned certain sentences of Sixtus the Pythagorean Philosopher and attributed them to St. Sixtus, Pontiff and Martyr, as Jerome testifies in the letter to Ctesiphon. St. Augustine too, deceived by Rufinus's version, thought those sentences were St. Sixtus the Martyr's; which he retracts, Retractations book 2, chapter 46 [42]. These sentences are extant in volume 5 of the Library of the Holy Fathers, second edition. He turned besides into the Latin tongue the Recognitions of Clement, as Gennadius testifies in the book On Illustrious Men. But as the Recognitions themselves are perhaps falsely attributed to Clement, so too it is not incredible that the preface of Rufinus, as translator, was falsely joined to them. Lastly Rufinus is rightly marked for error by Pope Gelasius, chapter Sancta Romana, distinction 15.

Palladius the Galatian. 390

Palladius the Galatian was a contemporary and friend of Rufinus, as can be understood from his works. He wrote the Lausiac History and the Paradise of Heraclides, in which are briefly described the lives of many saints, which can bring no small profit to readers. He himself, however, is blamed as an Origenist by St. Jerome in the letter to Ctesiphon, and by St. Epiphanius in the letter to John of Jerusalem, which is extant in the second volume of St. Jerome. There is extant also a certain dialogue under the name of Palladius in the first volume of the works of St. John Chrysostom, Paris edition.

St. Gaudentius of Brescia. 390

St. Gaudentius, the successor of Philastrius in the episcopate of Brescia, wrote most useful treatises on various subjects, which are extant in volume 2 of the Library of the Holy Fathers, second edition: On the dedication of a Basilica, 1 treatise; On Easter, on Exodus, 7; On the reading of the Gospel, 2; On Exodus again, 1; On the paralytic, 1; on the words, Now is the judgement of the world, 1; On the promise of the Paraclete, 1; On the Machabee Martyrs, 1; On the unjust Steward, to Germinius, 1; on the words, The Father is greater than I, 1.

Aurelius Prudentius. 390

Aurelius Prudentius, the Christian poet, flourished under Theodosius the elder and his sons. He wrote excellent poems: the Psychomachia, on the battle of faith and idolatry, of chastity and lust, of patience and anger, of pride and humility, of luxury and sobriety, of avarice and generosity, of concord and discord. He wrote the book Cathemerinon, that is, of the things of the day, in which are contained hymns from Matins to Vespers. He wrote the book Peristephanon, that is, on the crowns, in which are the praises of many Martyrs: St. Lawrence, St. Vincent, St. Eulalia, Saints Peter and Paul, St. Agnes, St. Cyprian, St. Cassian and others. He wrote the Apotheosis, that is, on the Godhead, where there are hymns against unbelievers, against the Sabellian Heretics, against the Jews; likewise on the nature of the soul and on the resurrection of the flesh. He wrote the Hamartigenia, that is, on the origin of sins, against Marcion. He wrote two books against Symmachus. Gennadius adds, in the book On Illustrious Men, that there were written by him also an enchiridion of the old and new Testament, and on the work of the six days.

St. Chromatius, Bishop of Aquileia. 399

St. Chromatius was a most holy and most learned Bishop, by the testimony of St. Jerome in the preface to the book of Paralipomenon. He is said to have written commentaries on Matthew; but now there are extant only homilies on the eight beatitudes in Matthew 5, and a treatise on the words, “I ought to be baptized by thee.” See the Library of the Holy Fathers, volume 2. There is extant in the fourth volume of the works of St. Jerome a letter under the name of Chromatius and Heliodorus to Jerome, and Jerome's answer, in which the birth of the most Blessed Virgin is treated; but both are false and forged; as also Cardinal Baronius proves false the letter of the same Chromatius and Heliodorus to Jerome about the martyrology. See Cardinal Baronius's preface to the Roman martyrology, chapters 3 and 7.

St. John Chrysostom. 398

St. John Chrysostom, the great Doctor of the Church, first worked in the courts with great praise; then he practised the monastic life, and, called from the desert to the clergy, was ordained Presbyter of Antioch in the 11th year of Valentinian the younger and the 8th of Theodosius the elder; then in the 4th year of Arcadius and Honorius he was made Bishop of Constantinople; at last, in the 13th year of the same emperors and the ninth of his episcopate, he died, about the year of the Lord 407. The works that are extant are comprised in five volumes in the Venice edition of the year of the Lord 1574; for I was using this edition while I wrote.

The first volume: on Genesis, 67 homilies; on the Psalms, 26; on various places of the old Testament, 52, of which five are on the vision of Isaias.
The second volume: on Matthew, 89 homilies [90?]; on the same, of the unfinished work, 54; on various places of Matthew, 26; on Mark, 14; on various places of Luke, 7.
The third volume: on John, 78 [88?] homilies; on various places of John, 6; on the Acts of the Apostles, 51 [55?]; sermons on the sacred feasts, 32; on various places of Paul, 14, among which are many on the praises of Paul.
The fourth volume: Commentaries by homilies on all the letters of blessed Paul.
The fifth volume: to the People of Antioch, 80 homilies; On the priesthood, dialogues or books, 6; On compunction of heart, 2 books; On the providence of God, 6 books [3?]; On praying to God, 2 books; On the comparison of the king and the monk, 1; Against the detractors of the monastic life, 3; Against the Gentiles, or on Babylas the martyr, 1; sermons on penance, 12; sermons against the Jews and Heretics, 15; sermons against those who keep concubines, 2; sermons on various subjects, 48; Letters, 8: to Pope Innocent, 2; to Cyriacus, 1; to the Bishops and Presbyters shut in prison for piety, 1; to Theodore who had fallen, 2; to Eutropius, 1; to Olympias, a noble woman, 1; the Liturgy, or Mass, of St. John Chrysostom.

Note. In the first volume, among the homilies on various places of the old Testament, is a homily on Genesis 2 which begins “God the founder of the world”; which homily does not seem possibly Chrysostom's, since two whole chapters are inserted in it from the Latin book On Church dogmas, namely the thirty-first and thirty-second. And that book has an author later than Chrysostom, as we shall say below. Some others too there are that may seem of doubtful faith. But the homilies on Genesis, on the Psalms, on the vision of Isaias, and very many others are undoubted.

In the second volume the Commentaries on Matthew are without doubt Chrysostom's. But the unfinished work does not seem to be Chrysostom's; for there was no reason why the same author should write so much twice on the same subject. But whoever's work it is, it was either composed by some heretic or corrupted by some heretic, though otherwise the book is learned and by no means to be despised. In homily 4 it says “that the Holy Spirit is the minister of the Son”, and in homily 48 it counts the homoousians among the Heretics; which two opinions are the Arians'. But on the contrary in homilies 28 and 44 it says that those are Heretics who affirm that the Son is less than the Father; which is contrary to what was said above. So it is credible that the author was a Catholic, but that his work was depraved by the Arians. In the same volume are commentaries on Mark, which without doubt are not Chrysostom's, but of some simple Monk who was explaining the Gospel to his brethren, as is clear from homilies 3, 4, 8 and 9 and from others. Of the others found in the same volume, some are plainly Chrysostom's, as the homily on the betrayal of Judas; likewise on the rich man and Lazarus, homily 4; and another on the Publican and the Pharisee, and another on the cross and the thief. The rest seem taken partly from Chrysostom's Commentary on Matthew, partly from the unfinished work, partly from the homilies on Mark.

In the third volume the 87 [88?] homilies on John are by the consent of all Chrysostom's. I think the same must be judged altogether of the 55 homilies on the Acts of the Apostles, though they are called into doubt by Erasmus. Certainly in homily 9 the author says he is a Bishop, and in homily 11 adds that he is Bishop of a very large City, and in homily 41 says he lived in the time of Julian the apostate, and in homily 52 says his name is John; nor is there anything of any weight from which a suspicion of a forged work can be gathered. Add that John Damascene, On the faith book 3, and Oecumenius, in the chain of explanation on the Acts, draw testimonies from these homilies under the name of St. John Chrysostom. Of the six homilies placed between the Commentaries on John and on the Acts it is not altogether certain whether they are Chrysostom's, except the third, which begins “The young of the swallows”. All the rest are believed to be Chrysostom's, and especially the homilies on the praises of Paul. In the fourth volume there is nothing that can rightly be called into doubt. In the fifth volume almost everything is certain and undoubted, except the homilies to the people of Antioch, of which only twenty-one are said to be found in manuscript in old libraries; and it is plainly gathered from their context that very many of them are fragments of Chrysostom's homilies on Matthew, or on John, or on the Acts of the Apostles, or on the letters of Paul. For example, the twenty-seventh homily to the people of Antioch is taken partly from homily 10, partly from 11, partly from 12 on the Acts; and homilies 60 and 61 to the people are taken from homily 83 on Matthew and 45 on John. But this does not much matter, since the sayings are of the same author.

Severian of Gabala. 398

Severian, Bishop of Gabala, is said to have been a most eloquent man; and Gennadius in the book On Illustrious Men writes that he read this Severian's exposition on the Letter to the Galatians, and certain other things; he adds also that he was often wont to be invited by St. John Chrysostom and by the emperor Arcadius to give sermons in the Church of Constantinople. There is extant one sermon of this Severian in the fifth volume of the works of St. John Chrysostom.

Show the Latin (Vives edition, OCR)
De  Theophilo  Alexandrino.  390. 
Theophilus  Alexandrinae  Ecclesiae  Episco¬ 
pus  Sancti  Hieronymi  aequalis,  ut  epistolae 
utriusque  invicem  scriptae  testantur,  scri¬ 
psit  epistolas  tres  Paschales,  quas  Sanctus 
Hieronymus  Latinas  fecit.  Atque  epistolae 
istae  satis  utiles  et  doctae  exstant  in  Biblio¬ 
theca  sanctorum  Patrum  tomo  iii;  scripsit 
praeterea  adversus  Origenem  et  alia  quorum 
meminit  Gennadius  in  lib.  de  viris  illustribus, 
sed  haec  non  exstant. 
De  Joanne  Episcopo  Hierosolymitano .  390. 
Joannes  Episcopus  Hierosolymitanus  vixit 
tempore  Sancti  Hieronymi,  ut  notum  est  ex 
contentionibus  inter  eos  non  semel  excitatis, 
scripsit,  teste  Gennadio,  librum  in  obtrecta¬ 
tores  studii  sui,  ostendens  se  non  esse  Ori- 
genistam.  Tribuitur  eidem  Joanni  liber  ad 
Caprasium  de  institutione  Monachi,  qui  ha¬ 
betur  in  Bibliotheca  sanctorum  Patrum  to¬ 
mo  ix.  edit.  2.  sed  hic  liber  videtur  scriptus 
ab  aliquo  longe  posteriore  :  siquidem  eo  in 
libro  dicit  auctor  se  esse  ordinis  Carmelita- 
rum,  et  describit  habitum  Carmelitarum  :  at 
illis  temporibus  nomen  Carmelitarum  reli¬ 
giosorum  erat  plane  inauditum,  ut  etiam 
Card.  Baronius  affirmat,  tomo  vi.  Anna¬ 
lium,  ad  annum  444.  Adde  quod  stylus  est 
hominis  Latini,  et  temporum  posteriorum. 
De  Diadocho.  390. 
Diadochus  Episcopus  Photices  scripsit  in¬ 
signem  librum  de  perfectione,  continentem 
capita  centum :  hic  liber  exstat  in  Bibliothe¬ 
ca  sanctorum  Patrum  tomo  quinto,  edit,  2. 
De  Dorotheo  Archimandrita. 
Porotheus  Archimandrita  scripsit  sermo- 
392 
DE  SCRIPTORIBUS  ECCLESIASTICIS 
nes  viginti  quatuor,  qui  exstant  in  bibliothe¬ 
ca  sanctorum  Patrum,  tomo  ii.  edit.  2.  Hi 
duo  quando  vixerint,  non  compertum  habeo, 
quamvis  antiquos  fuisse  satis  constet. 
De  Ruffino  Presbytero.  390. 
Ruffinus  Presbyter  Aquileiensis  ,  Sancti 
Hieronymi  quondam  amicissimus,  deinde 
aemulus  factus,  scripsit  libros  duos  historiee 
Ecclesiasticae,  quos  addidit  ad  historiam 
Eusebii  Caesariensis  a  se  conversam  ex  Grae¬ 
co  :  scripsit  etiam  explicationem  symboli 
Apostoloci  :  item  in  Psalmos  aliquot  com¬ 
mentaria  ;  invectivas  duas  in  Sanctum  Hie¬ 
ronymum  ;  et  apologiam  pro  Origene,  in  qua 
multa  mentitur,  ipso  Hieronymo  teste  in  se¬ 
cunda  apologia  :  scripsit  quoque  multas  epi¬ 
stolas.  Haec  omnia  exstant,  partim  inter 
opera  Sancti  Hieronymi,  partim  in  historia 
Eusebii,  partim  etiam  seorsim.  Vertit  quas¬ 
dam  sententias  Sixti  Philosophi  Pythago¬ 
rici,  easque  tribuit  Sancto  Sixto  Pontifici  et 
Martyri,  ut  testatur  Hieronymus  in  epistola 
ad  Ctesiphontem.  Sanctus  etiam  Augustinus 
ex  versione  Ruffini  deceptus,  eas  sententias 
esse  putavit  Sancti  Sixti  Martyris ;  quod  re¬ 
tractat.  lib.  ii.  retract.  cap.  46.  Hae  senten¬ 
tiae  exstant  in  tomo  quinto  bibliothecae  san¬ 
ctorum  Patrum,  editionis  secundae.  Vertit 
praeterea  in  Latinam  linguam  recognitiones 
Clementis,  ut  Gennadius  testatur  in  lib.  de 
Viris  illustribus.  Sed  sicut  ipsae  recognitio¬ 
nes  falso  fortasse  tribuuntur  Clementi,  ita 
etiam  non  est  incredibile,  falso  adjunctam 
illis  fuisse  praefationem  Ruffini,  quasi  inter¬ 
pretis;  denique  Ruffinus  merito  notatur  er¬ 
roris  a  Gelasio  Papa,  cap.  Sancta  Romana, 
distinet.  15. 
De  Palladio  Galata.  390. 
Palladius  Galata,  Ruffini  aequalis  et  ami¬ 
cus  fuit  :  ut  ex  operibus  ejus  intelligi  potest. 
Scripsit  historiam  Lausiacam,  et  Paradisum 
Heraclidis,  in  quibus  describuntur  breviter 
multorum  sanctorum  vitae,  quae  non  modi¬ 
cam  praestare  possunt  legentibus  utilitatem. 
Ipse  tamen  reprehenditur,  ut  Origenista,  a 
S.  Hieronymo  in  epistola  ad  Ctesiphontem, 
et  a  S.  Epiphanio  in  epistola  ad  Joannem 
Hierosolymitanum,  quae  exstat  in  secundo 
tomo  S.  Hieronymi.  Exstat  etiam  dialogus 
quidam  sub  nomine  Palladii  in  tomo  primo 
operum  S.  Joannis  Chrysostomi,  editionis 
Parisiensis. 
De  S.  Gaudentio  Brixiensi.  390. 
Sanctus  Gaudentius  successor  Philastrii 
in  Episcopatum  Brixiae,  scripsit  utilissimos 
tractatus  de  variis  arg  umentis,  qui  exstant 
in  tomo  n.  bibliothecae  S.  Patrum  editio¬ 
nis  ii. 
De  dedicatione  Basilicae,  tractatus  1 
De  Pascha  in  Exodum,  7 
De  lectione  Evangelii,  2 
De  Exodo  iterum,  1 
De  paralytico,  1 
In  illud,  nunc  judicium  est  mundi,  1 
De  promissione  Paracleti,  1  . 
De  Macchabaeis  Martyribus,  1 
De  Villico  iniquitatis  ad  Germinium,  1 
In  illud,  Pater  major  me  est,  1 
De  Aurelio  Prudentio.  390. 
Aurelius  Prudentius  poeta  Christianus , 
floruit  sub  Theodosio  seniore,  et  filiis  ejus  : 
scripsit  egregia  carmina,  psychomachiam, 
de  pugna  fidei,  et  idololatriae  : ‘pudicitiae,  et 
libidinis;  patientiae,  et  irae  :  superbiae,  et 
humilitatis  :  luxuriae,  et  sobrietatis  :  avari¬ 
tiae,  et  largitatis  :  concordiae,  et  discordiae. 
Scripsit  librum  Cathemerinon,  id  est,  re¬ 
rum  diurnarum,  in  quo  continentur  hymni 
a  Matutino  ad  Vespertinum. 
Scripsit  librum  Peristephanon,  id  est,  de 
coronis,  in  quo  sunt  laudes  multorum  Mar¬ 
tyrum,  S.  Laurentii,  S.  Vincentii,  S.  Eula- 
liae,  SS.  Petri  et  Pauli,  S.  Agnetis,  S.  Cy¬ 
priani,  S.  Cassiani,  et  aliorum. 
Scripsit  Apotheosim,  id  est,  de  divinitate, 
ubi  sunt  hymni  in  infideles,  in  Haereticos 
Sabellianos,  in  Judaeos;  item  de  natura  ani¬ 
mae,  et  de  resurrectione  carnis. 
Scripsit  Amartingenia,  id  est,  de  origine 
peccatorum ;  contra  Marcionem. 
Scripsit  libros  duos  contra  Symmachum. 
Addit  Gennadius  in  libro  de  viris  illustri¬ 
bus,  scripta  quoque  fuisse  ab  eo,  enchiri¬ 
dion  veteris  et  novi  Testamenti,  et  de  opere 
sex  dierum. 
De  S.  Chr ornatio  Episcopo  Aquileiensi.  399. 
Sanctus  Chromatius  Episcopus  sanctissi¬ 
mus  et  doctissimus  fuit  testimonio  S.  Hiero¬ 
nymi,  praefatione  in  librum  Paralip.  Seri- 
AB  ANNO  DOM.  300.  AD  400. 
psisse  fertur  commentaria  in  Matthaeum; 
sed  nunc  exstant  solum  homilise  de  octo  bea- 
titudinibus  in  cap.  v.  Matthaei,, et  tractatus  in 
illud,  «  Ego  a  te  debeo  baptizari.  »  Yide  in 
bibliotheca  S.  Patrum  tomo  2. 
Exstat  in  quarto  tomo  operum  S.  Hiero¬ 
nymi  epistola  sub  nomine  Ghromatii,  et  He¬ 
liodori  ad  Hieronymum,  et  responsio  Hiero¬ 
nymi,  in  quibus  agitur  de  nativitate  Beatis¬ 
simae  Virginis  :  sed  utraque  falsa  et  suppo- 
posititia  est  :  ut  etiam  falsam  esse  convincit 
Card.  Baronius  epistolam  eorumdem  Chro- 
matii  et  Heliodori  ad  Hieronymum  circa 
martyrologium.  Vide  praefationem  Card.  Ba- 
ronii  ad  martyrologium  Romanum,  cap.  3* 
et  7. 
De  S.  Joanne  Chrysostomo.  398. 
Sanctus  Joannes  Chrysostomus,  magnus 
Ecclesiae  Doctor,  primum  in  foro  versatus 
est  magna  cum  laude  :  deinde  monasticam 
vitam  exercuit,  atque  ab  eremo  ad  clerum 
vocatus,  Presbyter  Antiochenus  ordinatus 
est  anno  1 1 .  Valentiniani  junioris  et  8.  Theo¬ 
dosii  senioris  :  anno  deinde  4.  Arcadii  et 
Honorii  Episcopus  Gonstantinopolitanus  fa¬ 
ctus;  tandem  anno  13.  eorumdem  impera¬ 
torum,  et  episcopatus  sui  nono,  mortem 
obiit  circa  annum  Domini  407.  Opera,  quae 
exstant,  quinque  tomis  comprehenduntur, 
in  editione  Veneta  anni  Domini  1574;  hac 
enim  editione  utebar  dum  scriberem. 
Tomi  primi  : 
In  Genesim  homiliae,  67 
In  Psalmos  homiliae,  26 
In  varia  loca  Testamenti  veteris,  52 
Ex  quibus  quinque  sunt  de  visione  Isaiae. 
Secundi  tomi  : 
In  Matthaeum  homiliae, 
89 
In  eumdem  operis  imperfecti  hom. 
54 
In  varia  loca  Matthaei  hom. 
26 
In  Marcum  hom. 
14 
In  varia  loca  Lucae  hom. 
7 
'  Tertii  tomi  : 
In  Joannem  hom. 
78 
In  varia  loca  Joannis  hom. 
6 
In  Acta  Apostolorum  hom. 
51 
Conciones  de  sacris  feriis, 
32 
393 
In  varia  loca  Pauli  hom.  14 
ln  quibus  sunt  multae  de  laudibus  Pauli. 
Quarti  tomi  : 
Commentaria  per  homilias  in  omnes  episto¬ 
las  B.  Pauli. 
Quinti  tomi : 
Ad  Populum  Antiochenum  hom.  80 
De  sacerdotio  dialogi,  sive  libri,  6 
De  compunctione  cordis,  lib.  2 
De  providentia  Dei,  lib.  6 
De  orando  Deo,  lib.  2 
De  comparatione  regis  et  monachi.  1 
Contra  vituperatores  vitae  monasticae,  3 
Contra  Gentiles,  sive  in  Babylam  marty¬ 
rem,  1 
De  poenitentia  sermones.  12 
Adversus  Judaeos,  et  Haereticos  serm.  15 
Contra  Concubinarios  serm.  2 
Variorum  argumentorum  serm.  48 
Epistolae.  8 
Ad  Innocentium  Papam.  '  2 
Ad  Cyriacum.  1 
Ad  Episcopos  et  Presbyteros  ob  pieta¬ 
tem  in  carcere  inclusos,  1 
Ad  Theodorum  lapsum,  2 
Ad  Eutropium,  1 
Ad  Olympiam  illustrem  feminam,  1 
Liturgia,  sive  Missa  S.  Jo.  Chrysostomi. 
Observatio. 
In  primo  tomo  ex  homiliis  in  diversa  loca 
Testamenti  veteris  est  homilia  in  cap.  ii. 
Gen.  quae  incipit,  «  Deus  institutor  mundi  »  : 
quae  homilia  non  videtur  posse  esse  Chryso¬ 
stomi,  cum  in  ea  inserta  sint  duo  integra 
capita  ex  libro  Latino  de  Ecclesiasticis  do¬ 
gmatibus,  videlicet  tricesimum  primum,  et 
tricesimum  secundum.  Liber  autem  iste  ha¬ 
bet  auctorem  Chrysostomo  posteriorem,  ut 
infra  dicemus.  Aliae  quoque  nonnullae  sunt, 
quae  dubiae  fidei  videri  possunt.  Sed  homi¬ 
liae  in  Genesim,  et  in  Psalmos,  et  de  visione 
Isaiae,  et  aliae  plurimae  indubitatae  sunt. 
In  secundo  tomo  Commentaria  in  Mat¬ 
thaeum  sine  dubio  Chrysostomi  sunt.  Sed 
opus  imperfectum  non  videtur  esse  Chryso¬ 
stomi  :  non  enim  erat  ulla  ratio ,  cur  bis  de 
argumento  eodem  tam  multa  idem  auctor 
scriberet.  Sed  cujuscumque  sit  opus,  aut  ab 
394 
DE  SCRIPTORIBUS  ECCLESIASTICIS 
haeretico  aliquo  compositum  fuit,  aut  ab 
haeretico  aliquo  corruptum,  quamvis  alio- 
qui  liber  sit  doctus,  et  minime  spernendus. 
Hom.  4.  dicit  «  Spiritum  sanctum  esse  mini¬ 
strum  Filii»  :  et  hom.  48.  homousianos  nu¬ 
merat  inter  Haereticos  :  quae  duae  sententiae 
Arianorum  sunt.  Contra  tamen  hom.  28.  et 
44.  dicit,  Haereticos  esse,  qui  affirmant,  Fi¬ 
lium  esse  minorem  patre :  quae  superioribus 
dictis  contraria  sunt ;  proinde  credibile  est 
auctorem  fuisse  Catholicum,  sed  opus  illius 
ab  Arianis  esse  depravatum. 
In  eodem  tomo  sunt  commentaria  in  Mar¬ 
cum,  quae  sine  dubio  Chrysostomi  non  sunt, 
sed  alicujus  simplicis  Monachi,  qui  fratribus 
suis  Evangelium  explicabat,  ut  constat  ex 
hom.  3.  4.  8.  9.  et  ex  aliis.  Ex  aliis,  quae  in  eo¬ 
dem  tomo  habentur,  quaedam  sunt  manifeste 
Chrysost.  ut  homilia  de  proditione  Judae; 
item  de  divite,  et  Lazaro ;  hom.  4.  et  alia  de 
Publicano,  et  Pharisaeo,  et  alia  de  cruce,  et 
latrone.  Reliqua  videntur  excerpta  partim  ex 
Comm.  Chrys.  in  Mat.  partim  ex  opere  im¬ 
perfecto,  partim  ex  ho.  in  Mare. 
Ip  tertio  tomo  hom.  87.  in  Joannem  om¬ 
nium  consensu  Chrysostomi  sunt.  Idem 
omnino  sentiendum  existimo  de  hom.  55. 
in  Acta  Apostolorum,  quamvis  ab  Erasmo 
revocentur  in  dubium.  Certe  hom.  9.  auctor 
Episcopum  se  esse  dicit,  et  hom.  11.  addit 
Episcopum  se  esse  Urbis  amplissimae,  et 
hom.  41.  dicit,  se  vixisse  tempore  Juliani 
apostatae,  et  hom.  52.  nomen  suum  dicit 
esse  Joannem  :  neque  est  aliquid  alicujus 
momenti,  unde  suspicio  supposititii  operis 
colligi  possit.  Adde  quod  Joannes  Damasce¬ 
nus  lib.  in.  de  fide,  et  QEcumenius  in  cate¬ 
na  explanationis  in  Acta,  testimonia  petunt 
ex  his  homiliis  sub  nomine  S.  Jo.  Chryso¬ 
stomi.  De  sex  homiliis  interpositis  inter 
Commentaria  in  Joannem,  et  in  Acta,  non 
est  omnino  certum,  an  sint  Chrysostomi, 
excepta  tertia,  quae  incipit,  «  Hirundinum 
pulli.  »  Reliqua  omnia  creduntur  esse  Chry¬ 
sostomi,  ac  praesertim  homiliae  de  laudibus 
Pauli. 
In  quarto  tomo  nihil  est,  quod  jure  revo¬ 
cari  possit  in  dubium 
In  quinto  tomo  omnia  fere  sunt  certa,  et 
indubitata,  exceptis  homiliis  ad  populum 
Antiochenum,  ex  quibus  viginti  et  una  tan- 
tum  reperiri  dicuntur  raanuscriptaa  in  antir 
quis  bibliothecis  :  et  aperte  colligitur  ex 
contextu  ipsarum,  permultas  earum  esse 
fragmenta  homiliarum  ChryBostomi  in  Mat¬ 
thaeum,  vel  in  Joannem,  vel  in  Acta  Apo¬ 
stolorum,  vel  in  epistolas  Pauli,  ut  exempli 
gratia,  homilia  ad  populum  Antiochenum 
vicesima  septima  decerpta  est  partim  ex 
hom.  10.  partim  ex  1 1 .  partim  ex  12  in  Acta, 
et  hom.  60.  et  61.  ad  ^populum  decerptae 
sunt  ex  hom.  83.  in  Matthaeum,  et  45.  in 
Joannem.  Sed  hoc  non  multum  refert,  cum 
sententiae  ejusdem  auctoris  sint. 
De  Severiano  Gabalensi.  398. 
Severianus  Episcopus  Gabalensis,  vir  elo- 
quentissimus  dicitur  fuisse  :  et  Gennadius 
in  lib.  de  viris  illustr.  scribit  se  legisse  hujus 
Severiani  expositionem  in  Epistolam  ad  Ga¬ 
latas,  et  alia  quaedam ;  addit  etiam,  illum 
saepe  invitari  solitum  a  S.  Joanne  Chryso- 
stomo,  et  ab  Arcadio  Imperatore  ad  sermo¬ 
nes  habendos  in  Ecclesia  Constantinopoli- 
tana.  Exstat  hujus  Severiani  sermo  unus  in 
quinto  tomo  operum  S.  Joannis  Chrysosto¬ 
mi. 
← Chapter 14Chapter 16 →